What if I fear that someone I love is lost?
Defined dogma Common teaching
What the Church holds
- Defined dogma Judgement belongs to God, at "the very moment of his death" (CCC 1022).
- Common teaching No one on earth can see it. The Church's Eucharistic prayer has always prayed "in general for all who have fallen asleep before us" (St Cyril of Jerusalem, quoted in CCC 1371). Benedict XVI: "It is never too late to touch the heart of another, nor is it ever in vain" (Spe Salvi 48).
- So pray: if they are in Purgatory, your prayer helps them; if not, "our prayer is not lost" (FAU-09).
What the saints and mystics report
Private revelation The accounts are full of last-moment salvation:
- a woman of bad reputation saved by one sentence of acceptance (SIM-05);
- "two or three minutes to say yes" (SIM-R1);
- a duelling prince saved by contrition (EMO-83);
- a supposed libertine saved by secret alms (VIS-11);
- a man who mocked the Church, saved by a stranger's whispered prayer (SIM-31).
The lowest level, the witnesses say, is full of those an onlooker would have called lost (see VIII-A, The Witnesses’ Map of Purgatory).
Accounts that bear on this
- SIM-05Maria Simma: A woman of bad reputation killed by a train is saved by one sentence of acceptance (Eltz (Simma): straight to Heaven; Sr Emmanuel (Simma): …
- SIM-R1Maria Simma: Death and judgement: the souls judge themselves and choose their level; the light at death; the "film" of one's …
- EMO-83Marie-Denise: Sr Marie-Denise (Visitation): the duellist prince saved by contrition but sentenced "until the Day of Judgment"; her …
- VIS-11The Portuguese visionary: A man thought a libertine was saved by secret alms; those he helped pray for him without knowing it
- SIM-31Maria Simma: A man who mocked the Church on a train in 1932 was saved by her whispered prayer