Can a soul in Purgatory be lost — can it go to Hell?
Defined dogma
No. The soul in Purgatory is confirmed in grace. It can no longer sin, and it is absolutely certain of its salvation. The only question is when — not whether — it will enter into the glory of Heaven. The councils describe them as those who die 'truly repentant in charity' (Lyons II) or 'in the love of God' (Florence), and the Catechism as those who 'die in God's grace and friendship' (CCC 1030). Because they died in grace, their salvation is certain (Benedictus Deus, 1336).
Private revelation What the saints and mystics add
Joy and pain together; Our Lady, the angels and St Michael among the souls.
Accounts that bear on this
- CGE-R5Catherine of Genoa: The souls cannot reflect on their sins or compare themselves with others; no will left but pure love; they can …
- UMP-R8Sr Mary of the Cross (the Manuscript): Consolations: glimpses of Heaven "almost a punishment"; "martyrs, consumed as it were by love"; confirmed in grace; …